Most tune-up checklists in circulation are tick boxes. Filter — checked. Coil — checked. Electrical — checked. A furnace can pass every line of that sheet while it is over-firing by half an inch of water column, running a 95°F rise against a rating plate that stops at 70, and putting 450 ppm of carbon monoxide up the flue. Nothing on a box-ticking form catches any of it, and nothing on it gives the customer a reason to believe the visit happened at all.
This builder records the readings and grades them, and it grades most of them against the unit in front of you rather than a number we printed. Temperature rise is the clearest example. Every gas furnace rating plate states its own rise range — 30 to 60, 45 to 75, 50 to 80 — and the measured rise has to land inside that specific range. Below the minimum the blower is moving too much air and the heat exchanger can condense and corrode; at or above the maximum the furnace cycles on the high limit and the exchanger cooks, which is how they crack. There is no universal range to print, so the form makes you type the plate range in and then does the comparison.
The same discipline applies everywhere a number would be tempting. Capacitors are graded against the rated µF and the tolerance printed on the can — ±6% is what most OEM-grade HVAC run capacitors are marked to, but ±5% and ±10% parts are sold, so the tolerance is an editable field rather than a constant. Manifold pressure is compared to the rating plate, because 3.5 inches water column is a common natural-gas setting and not a specification; LP units sit near 10 to 11, and two-stage valves differ per stage. Static pressure is judged against the blower table figure, because grading every unit at 0.5 in. w.c. fails correctly installed high-static equipment. And evaporator ΔT is recorded against a target you enter, because target split moves with the humidity of the return air: the 18 to 22°F everyone quotes only holds near 45 to 55% relative humidity, and a correctly operating system on an 80°F dry-bulb, 71°F wet-bulb return legitimately reads about 15°F.
Carbon monoxide gets the most careful handling on the sheet, because it is the reading that can stop a job and the one most often quoted on the wrong basis. The 400 ppm threshold for a central furnace is AIR FREE — that is how the ANSI/BPI-1200 thresholds table, the National Fuel Gas Code and the ANSI Z21.47 appliance listing all state it. It is routinely confused with the BPI Building Analyst 26 / 100 / 400 ppm action levels, which are undiluted flue gas and are a different measurement from a different document. This form says which basis it is applying, converts your as-measured reading using the flue O₂ when you enter it, and flags anything above 100 ppm air free as worth chasing even though it is technically inside the standard.