A home inspection HVAC checklist and a contractor’s tune-up checklist look similar and are not the same document. A service technician diagnoses, measures, dismantles and repairs. A home inspector performs a visual, non-invasive inspection under a published standard of practice, reports what was observed on one day, and is bound as much by what the standard excludes as by what it requires. Most HVAC checklists in circulation are the technician’s document with an inspector’s cover page, which is exactly how an inspector ends up with a report that exceeds their own standard of practice in writing.
The temperature differential is where this shows up most clearly. Nearly every form prints a supply-and-return split with a “14 to 22 degrees” range beside it as though it were universal. It is not. InterNACHI 3.5.IV prescribes no range at all, and goes further by excluding determination of “the uniformity, temperature, flow, balance, distribution, size, capacity, BTU, or supply adequacy of the cooling system.” ASHI 9.2.B likewise excludes determining cooling supply adequacy. Texas is the outlier: 22 TAC §535.230(b)(1)(A)(ii) requires the inspector to measure and report the difference between supply and return air, and (b)(1)(B)(ii)(I) reports as Deficient a system that “fails to achieve a 15 degrees Fahrenheit to 22 degrees Fahrenheit temperature differential.” That range entered the rule by the amendment effective 1 February 2022, which is why downloads copied from the older rule disagree with each other. So this builder asks which standard you work to, grades the differential only where a standard actually prescribes a range, and otherwise records the number and says in the report that no range is prescribed. A fabricated threshold on a document a buyer will act on is the failure worth engineering around.
The same discipline runs through the rest of the form. The outdoor temperature floor below which cooling equipment need not be operated is 60°F under TREC §535.230(d)(3)(C)(i) and 65°F under InterNACHI 3.5.IV — two different numbers, so the report resolves it from your standard rather than printing one. Heat exchanger integrity is excluded by all three bodies and appears as a stated limitation rather than a line the inspector quietly leaves blank. Gas leaks at the heating equipment are required reporting under TREC §535.230(a)(3)(A) and excluded outright by InterNACHI 3.6.IV, so the item is flagged per standard instead of guessed at. “Flame rollout” is carried as the field term it is, because it appears in no model code and no standard of practice — the rule’s own words are “flame impingement, uplifting flame, improper flame color, or excessive scale buildup.” Where a code section is cited it names its edition, because these move: condensate disposal is M1411.3 in the 2021 IRC and M1411.9 in the 2024. And every export states that codes are not retroactive, because a 1985 house is not in violation of a 2021 code and a report that implies otherwise misrepresents the property.